[Date Index]
[Thread Index]
[Author Index]
Re: A kernel, multiple notebooks, and Global?
*To*: mathgroup at smc.vnet.net
*Subject*: [mg87738] Re: A kernel, multiple notebooks, and Global?
*From*: Bill Rowe <readnews at sbcglobal.net>
*Date*: Wed, 16 Apr 2008 05:05:50 -0400 (EDT)
On 4/15/08 at 5:51 AM, siegman at stanford.edu (AES) wrote:
>Pardon any awkward wordings here, but I may not have all the jargon
>relevant to my query clearly understood.
>Suppose that on a single-user computer I have several notebooks open
>that address different parts of a common calculation, and thus share
>overlapping sets of globally used variable names.
>The broad question is then, how far can I go -- or what dangers may
>lurk -- in treating these multiple notebooks as essentially one
>unified notebook that just happens to be stored in multiple files
>and appear on screen in multiple windows?
The only real issue here is your being able to keep track of
what is going on. That is I am confident, long before you run
out of resources (memory etc) you will have too many windows to
be convenient for your use.
>1) For example, in terms of contexts or scopes, I'm guessing that
>"Global is Global": the Global` context for all of these notebooks
>is set by or recorded by the kernel, and at any one instant is
>exactly the same for all these open notebooks -- right?
Right.
>2) Suppose a certain Input cell is present in exactly identical
>form at some random (i.e., different) point in each of the
>notebooks; I've been executing cells from all of the notebooks in
>some irregular sequence; and then I execute this particular cell in
>whichever of the notebooks happens to be most convenient for me.
Right. But you will need to be careful about dependencies in
each of the notebooks.
>I assume the kernel is likely to be able to recognize which notebook
>submitted these Input instructions.
I think this implies more tracking done by the kernel than is
the case. I believe the kernel simply sees every thing as a
sequence of operations and simply sends results back to which
ever notebook was the evaluation notebook at the time. That is,
I don't believe once you have evaluated several expressions in
several notebooks there is a means within Mathematica to find
the notebook containing say the 10th expression that was evaluated.
>But beyond that, unless this cell contains some code which directly or
>indirectly identifies the notebook in which the cell resides, and uses
>this information to modify the Input instructions, executing the copy
>of this cell that resides in any of the notebooks will produce exactly
>the same result, except for where it displays its output -- right?
Right. But watch out for unexpected dependencies. It is really
easy when working in this manner to miss a change in a variable
in one notebook that impacts another notebook.
Prev by Date:
**Re: A kernel, multiple notebooks, and Global?**
Next by Date:
**Re: Package to 'graft' Lists onto Matrices**
Previous by thread:
**Re: A kernel, multiple notebooks, and Global?**
Next by thread:
** Re: A kernel, multiple notebooks, and Global?**
| |