Re: Re: Mathematica and F#
- To: mathgroup at smc.vnet.net
- Subject: [mg91652] Re: Re: Mathematica and F#
- From: "peter lindsay" <pl.0 at me.com>
- Date: Sun, 31 Aug 2008 04:31:10 -0400 (EDT)
- References: <200808271042.GAA21194@smc.vnet.net> <email@example.com>
please see comments inline below
2008/8/30 Jon Harrop <jon at ffconsultancy.com>:
> peter lindsay wrote:
>> I am not an expert in either Mathematica or functional programming,
>> is there really any appetite from Mathematica users to tie themselves
>> into a Microsoft product?
> I can understand that argument from the open source perspective but
> Mathematica users are obviously already tying themselves into proprietary
>> Would Haskell not be a safer bet?
> Haskell has its own trade-offs that I will happily discuss elsewhere.
I am not an expert in functional programming...
> Suffice to say that modern scientific computing is about writing many
> disposable "script" programs, e.g. for massaging, analysing and
not in my experience - no, not at all. Much of the work my colleagues are
involved in uses Fortran, IDL and to a much lesser extent C++ with
occasional scripting in perl or python. My Statistics colleagues use SAS and
my pure maths colleagues use GAP and Haskell amongst others. However, my
point was: does anyone really want to tie them selves in to Microsoft . By
the way, we also tend not to massage data.
>The risks associated with vendor lock-in are then tiny, of course.
with respect - not at all. The risks of lock-in are high and I would
recommend anyone considering "buying-in" completely to some proprietary
brand [ even including Mathematica ] to be extremely careful if their
professional careers are to depend on that vendor.
> So I would not hesitate to recommend both Mathematica and F# to working
> scientists. Not least because they compliment each other extremely well.
for the moment, maybe ....
> Dr Jon D Harrop, Flying Frog Consultancy
Prev by Date:
Re: light-weight PC to run Mathematica?
Next by Date:
Re: animated faces of polygon
Previous by thread:
Re: Mathematica and F#
Next by thread:
Re: Help to remove equivalent (redundant) solutions from