MathGroup Archive 2013

[Date Index] [Thread Index] [Author Index]

Search the Archive

(amusement) surprising result from PossibleZeroQ


Dear group,

 playing around with distributions, I experienced one of these "that's
strange!"-moments.

 Take the quantile of a Pareto distribution

test = Quantile[ParetoDistribution[k, a], q];
InputForm@test

ConditionalExpression[Piecewise[{{k/(1 - q)^a^(-1), q < 1}}, Infinity],
 0 <= q <= 1]

I thought the nesting of ConditionalExpression and Piecewise could
simplify and tried every possible combination of 4 functions; to no avail:

Block[{f = {Refine, Simplify, FullSimplify, PiecewiseExpand}},
 Length[funcs =
   Composition @@@ Flatten[Tuples[f, #] & /@ Range[Length@f], 1]]
 ]
340

DeleteCases[Through[funcs[test]], test]
{}

My expectation has been sth. like

test2 = Piecewise[{{k/(1 - q)^(1/a), 0 <= q < 1},
                   {Infinity, q == 1}},
                  Indeterminate];

and

FullSimplify[test2 - test] // InputForm
ConditionalExpression[0, 0 <= q <= 1]

looks good. But compare this to

PossibleZeroQ[test2 - test] // InputForm
ConditionalExpression[False, 0 <= q <= 1]

I decided to classify that as "funny" :)

MemberQ[Attributes@PossibleZeroQ, Listable]
True


Have fun with or without Mathematica!

  Peter



  • Prev by Date: Minimize Headscratcher
  • Next by Date: Re: Farewell to a friend
  • Previous by thread: Re: Minimize Headscratcher
  • Next by thread: Re: (amusement) surprising result from PossibleZeroQ