incompatibilities between releases of Mathematica (was: Mathematica Link for Excel and Excel 2000)
- To: mathgroup at smc.vnet.net
- Subject: [mg19293] incompatibilities between releases of Mathematica (was: Mathematica Link for Excel and Excel 2000)
- From: "P.J. Hinton" <paulh at wolfram.com>
- Date: Thu, 12 Aug 1999 22:34:47 -0400
- Organization: "Wolfram Research, Inc."
- References: <firstname.lastname@example.org> <email@example.com>
- Sender: owner-wri-mathgroup at wolfram.com
On 12 Aug 1999, Joseph Yoon wrote: > While we're on the subject, I've seen no explanations from WRI as to > why the changes that were made from v3 to v4 cause so many > applications and notebooks to "break" and the reasoning behind them. Perhaps you could help us out by describing in precise terms exactly what you mean by "broken." The likelihood that you will get your code working to your satisfcation will increase if you can post specific, minimal examples that reproduce the problems you've been running into. > Getting info about bugs and "incompatibilities" from WRI has never > been easy. Diagnosing compatibility problems is not as simple as looking at a general list of known issues and saying, "yup, that's the problem." Your effectiveness at resolving these types of difficulties hinges greatly upon your approach. If you send a notebook with 1000 lines of uncommented code to Technical Support or MathGroup and say something like "This doesn't work anymore. Why?" your're less likely to achieve a resolution to your problem in a reasonable amount of time. It is not out of negligence or malice on anyone's behalf that this happens, it is because the scope of the problem has not been sufficiently narrowed. There may be experts on the Mathematica language both at WRI and on MathGroup, but they may not necessarily be well versed in your choice of computational techniques or areas of research. If the example you send does not sufficiently isolate out the behavior, then the task of problem solving quickly becomes an exercise in soothsaying, which may lead nowhere rather quickly. Also, there are several instances where a user will discover a feature of the language that may be desirable from his or her standpoint, but it is undocumented. In subsequent releases, the user finds that code which relies on the feature may not function in the same manner. These types of incompatibilities cannot be predicted a priori, and the introduction to the Reference Guide in _The Mathematica Book_ cautions the user be vigilant in this respect. -- P.J. Hinton Mathematica Programming Group paulh at wolfram.com Wolfram Research, Inc. Disclaimer: Opinions expressed herein are those of the author alone.