MathGroup Archive 2007

[Date Index] [Thread Index] [Author Index]

Search the Archive

Re: & without #

  • To: mathgroup at
  • Subject: [mg73074] Re: & without #
  • From: albert <awnl at>
  • Date: Thu, 1 Feb 2007 03:27:04 -0500 (EST)
  • References: <epp68i$cv0$>

I think to fully understand the behaviour you need to learn about pure
functions (lookup Function in the helpbrowser) and the evaluation of
expressions. Both are covered in the documentation.

> From Built-in Functions/Cases, here is this (undocumented?) usage of &
> without #:

Basically the combination of # and & are just a shortcut for Function[]. #
is the argument of the function, or to be more precise the first argument,
you can adress other arguments with #1, #2, #3, ... and ## is the sequence
of all arguments given. For Function[] there is also the version with named
arguments, where you can use arbitrary variables as arguments like in:
Function[{x,y},x-y]. Also note that the body of the function, that is x-y
in this case is _not_ evaluated, before you call the function with or
without arguments. This you can see easily by just evaluating:


which will not be simplified to Function[2]!

Of course it is possible to define a function which does not make use of its
arguments, that is the body of the function does not contain any reference
to the arguments of the function. This is what happens here:
> L=Array[Random[Integer,10]&,20]
> {4,5,9,6,8,5,4,0,9,4,5,2,10,6,3,7,4,2,2,8}

This is from the usage message of Array:

Array[f, n] generates a list of length n, with elements f[i]

so the result is a list of length 20 with elements (Random[Integer,10]&)[i].
If you evaluate this for any argument, it will return a random number
between 0 and 10, and that's what the result is: a list of 20 random
numbers between 0 and 10. Because the body of the function is evaluated
only when the function is called, you get 20 different numbers in this

> Here is what happens without the &:
> L=Array[Random[Integer,10],20]
> {3[1],3[2],3[3],3[4],3[5],3[6],3[7],3[8],3[9],3[10],3[11],3[12],3[13],3[
>  14],3[15],3[16],3[17],3[18],3[19],3[20]}

here the result is a list of length 20 with elements 3[i], which comes by
the fact that Random[Integer,10] is evaluated before it is used for the
list generation and in your case happened to evaluate to 3. Now Array
builds a list with 3[i] for i from 1 to 20, and that's exactly the result
you have been seeing. Note that the 3 will change to any number between 0
and 10 when you reevaluate this definition of L.

> Can someone who understands this please explain as completely as you
> can, including how & and # work
> together, given the behavior of & alone. 

As said before, & without # is just a function which does not make use of
it's arguments, whether you give them to the function or not.

> This might help and I also post it to help illuminate for those who
> haven't seen this & usage; it is from Andrzej a while ago (Andrzej I
> hope you don't mind):
> In general it means a constant function. 

if constant means that the result is independent of the arguments given,
that's corrrect.

> For example 3& will return 3 
> with any argument. But the are at least two "special" functions,
> which will work like "variable constants" when used in this way. One
> of them is Random[]& (and various variants of it). Another is Unique
> [symbol]&, which on every evaluation will produce a unique name based
> on "symbol".

There is nothing special about Random[] or Unique[] here, they just happen
to be expressions which give a different result each time they are
evaluated, there are many more, like for example Date[]. The 3 in 3&
happens to always evaluate to 3, and (94+1) in (94+1)& happens to always
evaluate to 95. Nevertheless the sum is calculated each time you evaluate
the function, you can see what happens with:





  • Prev by Date: Re: sort and positon matrix element help
  • Next by Date: Re: Remote Kernel does nothing
  • Previous by thread: Re: & without #
  • Next by thread: Re: & without #