MathGroup Archive 2010

[Date Index] [Thread Index] [Author Index]

Search the Archive

Re: Mathematica Programming

  • To: mathgroup at
  • Subject: [mg108957] Re: Mathematica Programming
  • From: telefunkenvf14 <rgorka at>
  • Date: Thu, 8 Apr 2010 08:01:44 -0400 (EDT)
  • References: <hphbp3$llb$>

On Apr 7, 2:21 am, "David Park" <djmp... at> wrote:
> Very interesting question.
> I have never been able to understand the promotional material for
> webMathematica. Can one run webMathematica from a standard user web site
> provided by an ISP? Or does one have to have one's own server setup, and
> what would that consist of? Where would the Mathematica engine that drives
> webMathematica actually reside? (It would be nice to have an answer that I
> could operationally understand and not in some jargon.) Is webMathematica
> something accessible for ordinary Mathematica users and developers, or is it
> ultimately a high priced institutional type application? Is it available to
> Premier subscribers?
> If I recollect correctly, there is a possibility that in the near future WRI
> will provide a way so that anyone can read a Mathematica notebook on line in
> a web browser. Would this include the use of active controls and be able to
> utilize private packages?  Would this be an alternative to webMathematica?
> Lots of questions, but being able to communicate efficiently with people who
> don't presently have Mathematica is still the missing link.
> David Park
> djmp... at comcast.net 
> From: Nicholas Chung [mailto:nchun... at]
> I have Mathematica 7 but I was wondering how it compares to
> WebMathematica and WorkBench? Can I create full applications and
> interactive websites with Mathematica? How much control do I have over
> the user interface design?

I've actually been reading up on how to install WebMMA and showed the
setup instructions to the IT guys at my university. Their reaction
wasn't all that comforting. (Most of them don't deal with anything

Anyways, I was going to call in and suggest a couple of possible

1. WRI could provide a VMWare server appliance to significantly ease
the setup. Two reasons WRI might NOT want to do this. Copy protection
may not work as it should---I don't know, just a hunch---and the cost
involved with configuring, releasing, and maintaining virtual
appliances may not actually be worth it. Definitely adding cost, not
necessarily adding revenue.

2. WRI might instead consider a WebMathematica hosted solution. This
would be tricky too, as such a service could directly compete with
Mathematica itself---in other words: How in the would you price it
(without alienating users with aggressive price discrimination)? Most
of the people that would choose a hosted solution are probably like
me. That is, dabblers in something new, only trying out the WebMMA due
to the availability via Premier Service. Another potential problem
with the hosted idea would be cost of computing time (i.e., my bad
code burns up server time).

3. A hybrid of (1) and (2): WRI could configure a VM appliance,
bundled with WebMMA, that could be immediately uploaded and deployed
to a cloud hosting service such as Amazon. (Q: Has anyone used
Amazon's cloud computing services? I looked at the rates recently and
didn't think they looked too bad... just wondering about real world
experiences for pay-go computing.)

  • Prev by Date: Re: convert txt to binary file
  • Next by Date: Re: Mathematica Programming
  • Previous by thread: Re: Mathematica Programming
  • Next by thread: Re: Mathematica Programming