MathGroup Archive 2011

[Date Index] [Thread Index] [Author Index]

Search the Archive

CellContext - Not ready for primetime use (opinion).

  • To: mathgroup at
  • Subject: [mg115980] CellContext - Not ready for primetime use (opinion).
  • From: Jason Ledbetter <jasonbrent at>
  • Date: Fri, 28 Jan 2011 06:13:36 -0500 (EST)


Are any of you using CellContext with a user specified string successfully?
e.g., CellContext->"someThing`".

I've read the various threads on mathgroup that say "don't use that", but
I'm sometimes stubborn. :-)

I think I've come to the conclusion that CellContext just isn't ready for
prime-time use outside of what WRI is using it for, despite it being in the
documentation. Wolfram's support has been of very limited assistance as
everything they come up with takes two steps back.

Here's a simple example:


In the resulting document execute:

You'll observe that the result is "mine`" which exactly matches the
documentation and that the $ContextPath has been changed to include System`
and mine`[1].

Let's suppose you want to now customize something in the resulting notebook
like customize $ContextPath. The obvious way would be NotebookWrite and
NotebookEvaluate (this was a solution provided by some DatabaseLink
developer @ Wolfram)...

Back in the original notebook execute the following and watch the results:


The Context/ContextPath get changed back to Global`... which means anything
written to that document and executed through NotebookEvaluate[] completely
tears down any explicit context/path that was setup through other mechanisms
(like CellProlog[2]).

[1] This brings up a couple of issues.. for example customizing $ContextPath
without user intervention to include things like DatabaseLink`, etc.
[2] This leads to other novel problems... DockedCells get a different
context/path than that of the notebook itself resulting in situations where
buttons in the dock only do the correct thing on their second action...


  • Prev by Date: Finding the Local Minima of a somewhat complicated function
  • Next by Date: Re: adding a keyboard shortcut for double brackets
  • Previous by thread: Re: Finding the Local Minima of a somewhat complicated function
  • Next by thread: Re: CellContext - Not ready for primetime use (opinion).