       Re: How to check whether an infinite set is closed under addition?

• To: mathgroup at smc.vnet.net
• Subject: [mg124388] Re: How to check whether an infinite set is closed under addition?
• From: David Bevan <david.bevan at pb.com>
• Date: Wed, 18 Jan 2012 05:58:28 -0500 (EST)
• Delivered-to: l-mathgroup@mail-archive0.wolfram.com

```closedQ[base_]:=Module[{m=Most[base]},Complement[Select[Join[2 m,Plus@@@Subsets[m,{2}]],#<Last[base]&],m]=={}]
closedQ2[base_]:=Module[{m=Most[base]},Complement[Select[DeleteDuplicates@Join[2 m,Plus@@@Subsets[m,{2}]],#<Last[base]&],m]=={}]

closedQ@Range // Timing
closedQ2@Range // Timing
{4.375, True}
{1.141, True}

randomSet[n_,p_]:=Sort@RandomSample[Range[n],Floor[p n]]
s=randomSet[4000,.5];

closedQ@s//Timing
closedQ2@s//Timing
{4.438,False}
{1.125,False}

________________________________________
From: David Bevan [david.bevan at pb.com]
Sent: 17 January 2012 11:00
To: mathgroup at smc.vnet.net
Subject: [mg124388] Re: How to check whether an infinite set is closed under addition?

It is only necessary to explicitly test that 2*a_i is in the set.

Assuming base is sorted, I think I'd use:

closedQ[base_] :=
Module[{m = Most[base]},
Complement[Select[Join[2 m, Plus @@@ Subsets[m, {2}]], # < Last[base] &],
m] == {}]

(I've made some other optimisations / simplifications too.)

Replacing Join[] with DeleteDuplicates@Join[] may be faster, depending on the data.

David %^>

> test1Q[base_] :=
>  Module[{b = Flatten[Table[# i, {i, Last[base]/#}] & /@ base]},
>   Complement[b, base] == {}]
>
> The second test is the original one:
>
> test2Q[base_List] :=
>  Complement[
>    Select[Total[Subsets[Most[base], {2}], {2}], # <= Last[base] &],
>    base] == {}
>
> Now we define closedQ:
>
> closedQ[base_List] := test1Q[base] && test2Q[base]

```

• Prev by Date: Re: Cross reference - a further question.
• Next by Date: Simplification de formule/ Simplification of formula
• Previous by thread: Re: How to check whether an infinite set is closed under addition?
• Next by thread: How to simplify this code with variable number of nesting loops?