Re: NDSolve useless?
- To: mathgroup at smc.vnet.net
- Subject: [mg63826] Re: [mg63821] NDSolve useless?
- From: Pratik Desai <pdesai1 at umbc.edu>
- Date: Mon, 16 Jan 2006 02:16:53 -0500 (EST)
- References: <200601151043.FAA22735@smc.vnet.net>
- Sender: owner-wri-mathgroup at wolfram.com
Alberto Verga wrote:
>Hi,
>The following code takes above a minute CPU time (it solves a set of coupled
>ordinary differential equations):
>In[13]:=
>\!\(\(NV = 128;\)\[IndentingNewLine]
>\(tf = 1. ;\)\[IndentingNewLine]
>\(\[Delta] = 0.1;\)\[IndentingNewLine]
>\(a = 0.01;\)\[IndentingNewLine]
>\(x0 = Table[
>n/NV + a\ Sin[2 \[Pi]\ n/NV], {n, 1, NV}];\)\[IndentingNewLine]
>\(y0 = Table[\(-a\)\ Sin[2 \[Pi]\ n/NV], {n, 1, NV}];\)\[IndentingNewLine]
>\(difx = 2 \[Pi]\ \((x\_n[t] - x\_m[t])\);\)\[IndentingNewLine]
>\(dify = 2 \[Pi] \((y\_n[t] - y\_m[t])\);\)\[IndentingNewLine]
>\(deno =
>2\ NV \((Cosh[dify] - Cos[difx] + \[Delta]\^2)\);\)\[IndentingNewLine]
>\(equx = \(-Sinh[dify]\)/deno;\)\[IndentingNewLine]
>\(equy = Sin[difx]/deno;\)\[IndentingNewLine]
>\(sol =
>NDSolve[Flatten[
>Table[{\[IndentingNewLine]D[x\_n[t], t] ==
>Sum[equx, {m, 1, NV}], \[IndentingNewLine]D[y\_n[t], t] ==
>Sum[equy, {m, 1, NV}], \[IndentingNewLine]x\_n[0] ==
>x0[\([n]\)], \[IndentingNewLine]y\_n[0] ==
>y0[\([n]\)]}, {n, 1, NV}]], \[IndentingNewLine]Flatten[
>Table[{x\_n, y\_n}, {n, 1, NV}]], \[IndentingNewLine]{t, 0,
>tf}];\) // Timing\)
>Out[24]=
>{76.199 Second, Null}
>
>
>The same problem solved with function ode45 (or compiled in C or fortran),
>takes about (less than) 1 second (on
>the same computer). Is there a way to optimize this kind of *numerical*
>computation in Mathematica?
>
> Or is NDSolve useless?
>
>
I think I read somewhere in the documentation that NDSolve code is
about 1400 pages long. A bit hard to use but certainly not useless.
Again that is just my opinion
>(Remark: my question is not about computers but about the implementation of
>NDSolve, compared for exemple with other numerical packages; if you add
>Method->ExplicitRungeKutta, timing increases!)
>
>Alberto Verga
>
>
>
>Alberto Verga
>
>IRPHE - Université de Provence
>49, rue F. Joliot-Curie, BP 146,
>13384 Marseille, France
>Tél: 33 (0) 496139751 Fax: 33 (0) 496139709
>
>
>
>
>
>
- References:
- NDSolve useless?
- From: Alberto Verga <Alberto.Verga@laposte.net>
- NDSolve useless?