MathGroup Archive 2009

[Date Index] [Thread Index] [Author Index]

Search the Archive

creating Graphics using ParallelTable[]

  • To: mathgroup at
  • Subject: [mg99847] creating Graphics using ParallelTable[]
  • From: Jan-Philip Gehrcke <jgehrcke at>
  • Date: Sat, 16 May 2009 05:19:57 -0400 (EDT)

Hello all,

I generate "video frames" from time-consuming 3DPlot[]s (to export
them into a video file later on):

frame[x_] := Plot3D[... something big using x ...];
movieframes = Table[frame[x], {x, start, end, (end-start)/steps}];

I have a double core CPU; so now I would like to create these frames
in parallel with Mathematica 7, using ParallelTable[]. But I don't
derive any advantage from doing this:

My Windows taskmanager shows three "MathKernel.exe". When I use
ParallelTable[] for the described problem, only one "MathKernel.exe"
is working, causing 50% CPU load and using much RAM. The other two
"MathKernel.exe"s don't cause any load and almost don't use any RAM.

$ProcessorCount is 2, there is 1 "master" and 2 "local" in "Parallel
Kernel Status". The "parallelizeabletest" ParallelTable[$KernelID,
{10}] succeeds.

I tried `DistributeDefinitions[frame];` before invoking ParallelTable
[], but it did not change anything.

One core needs about 20 seconds to create one single frame without
displaying it: An extensive analytical function (among others there
are nested Coth[]s) has to be calculated with Plotpoints->100 option.

In my opinion - simply expressed - each core can take one `x` out of
the queue and create the corresponding 3DPlot Graphics object, while
the other core is doing the same. This should work, because the tasks
are totally independent and my way to use the Table[] is the least
complex one. I don't see the "data management overhead" that often
reduces or even prevents advantages from parallelizing, because each
core just needs to get the function definitions and a simple number:
`x` - no more overhead.

(At which point) do I think wrong or does Mathematica work weird (less

Is there a way for me to create these frames using all my CPU power?


Jan-Philip Gehrcke

  • Prev by Date: Re: Re: saving initialization cells as a .m file
  • Next by Date: Re: Exports to eps, pdf ImageSize
  • Previous by thread: Why "InputForm[x,NumberMarks->False]" can not return correctly in my
  • Next by thread: Re: creating Graphics using ParallelTable[]