MathGroup Archive 1993

[Date Index] [Thread Index] [Author Index]

Search the Archive

Re: Maximum value

Dennis Schaeffer asked:

> To Math Group

> I have data in the form of the following table. This represents
> two planes of z values in a 3D space. I would like to form one plane
> consisting of the maximum value from each plane.

> In[155]:=
> TableForm[zz=Table[Random[],{2},{3},{3}]]
> Out[155]//TableForm=
> 0.385028   0.396816   0.78796
> 0.396616   0.875504   0.915426
> 0.435056   0.704659   0.764165

> 0.941824   0.117716   0.948508
> 0.533694   0.812695   0.659503
> 0.79622    0.710284   0.752177

> I would like to obtain a single plane of maximum values as follows
> using the data from above.

> 0.941824   0.396816   0.948508
> 0.533694   0.875504   0.915426
> 0.79622    0.710284   0.764165

> In my actual problem the space would be larger and consist of many
> more planes. This seems like it should be very simple thing to do
> in Mathematica, but I have not been able to come up with an
> acceptable solution.

> Dennis Schaeffer
> Internet: schaeffer_dennis at

It appears that you have two matrices of equal dimensions and you
would like to form another matrix by comparing corresponding
entries of the two and choosing the larger entry in each case.  The
general operation here is of pasting two matrices together at
the entries with some function, in this case Max, to make a single
matrix. MapThread is made to do just this.

   (* Define the list of two matrices and use options of TableForm
      to display the rows of the matrix horizontally instead of
      vertically: *)

In[1]:= TableForm[zz=Table[Random[],{2},{3},{3}],
          TableDirections->{Column, Column, Row}, TableSpacing->{2, 0, 2}]

Out[1]//TableForm= 0.553675   0.846423  0.626045
                   0.678834   0.797578  0.524513
                   0.415326   0.140053  0.910571

                   0.0170931  0.548463  0.745329
                   0.923666   0.820561  0.392114
                   0.37765    0.317338  0.162082

In[2]:= MapThread[Max, zz, 2] //TableForm

Out[2]//TableForm= 0.553675   0.846423   0.745329

                   0.923666   0.820561   0.524513

                   0.415326   0.317338   0.910571

We can verify by inspection that the result of MapThread is the
entry-wise maximum.

   This method doesn't care how many matrices (planes in your
application) there are.  If zz contains n matrices, then the same

MapThread[Max, zz, 2]

will form the matrix of maxima, entry-wise.  It's also
generalizeable to a list of matrices which have more than two
dimensions.  The third argument of MapThread specifies the level
at which the matrices are pasted together.  With 3D matrices,
the entries would be at level 3, so an entry-wise maximum would
be computed with

MapThread[Max, zz, 3]

And n-dimensional matrices could be pasted at the entries with

MapThread[Max, zz, n]

Note that you can use any function f you want to do the pasting;
in this case, we wanted Max.  Also, even if the matrices have
n dimensions, you could decide to paste them together at a depth
of less than n.  The elements at level (n-1) of an n-D matrix are
lists of entries, like rows of a 2D matrix.  We could paste entire
rows of a list of n-D matrices together with

MapThread[f, {A, B, ..., Z}, n - 1]

The entries of the output matrix would be the results of expressions
of the form

f[ {a1, a2, ...}, {b1, b2, ...}, . . . , {z1, z2, ..., zn} ]

where {a1, a2, ...} is a row out of A, {b1, b2, ...} is the corresponding
one out of b, etc.

   A completely different attack on this problem would be to give the
Max operator a property that addition and multiplication have in
Mathematica:  the property of automatically descending into lists and
operating on corresponding elements.  It is this property, called
'Listable', that allows you to add matrices A and B entry-wise with the
simple notation

A + B

Mathematica gives you the freedom to assign attributes to functions,
so let's do that for Max.  It's best not to permanently modify
built-in functions, so we'll use Block to add functionality to Max
just for the duration of our computation.  Declaring 'Max' as local
to the Block will yield a Max which is cleared of all its normal
attributes, which we don't want to disturb if not necessary, so
we'll make sure to import the ordinary attributes and just add
Listable to them.


In[4]:= Block[{Max, attrMax = Attributes[Max]},
           Attributes[Max] = Prepend[attrMax, Listable];
           Max @@ zz
         ] //MatrixForm

Out[4]//MatrixForm= 0.553675   0.846423   0.745329

                    0.923666   0.820561   0.524513

                    0.415326   0.317338   0.910571


Robby Villegas
villegas at

  • Prev by Date: 3-Day Hands-On Mathematica Workshops in Santa Clara
  • Next by Date: interrupting
  • Previous by thread: Maximum value
  • Next by thread: problem with init.m in mma 2.2 on RS/6000